Skip to main content
Question Protected by user14897
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
added tag, since community has bumped question up to top of active stack anyway
Link
quiet flyer
  • 23k
  • 5
  • 47
  • 135
Bumped by Community user
Bumped by Community user
Tweeted twitter.com/StackAviation/status/1245456080936804353
Post Reopened by quiet flyer, Sophie Swett, Ralph J, Machavity, CGCampbell
tags, typos, syntax
Source Link
quiet flyer
  • 23k
  • 5
  • 47
  • 135

We had a discussion with friend and we were talking about if the airplane is on approach and the one is landing with tailwind and the other one is landing with headwind, so both have the same value of IAS but the different value of ground speed. Sodoes it means thatWill the airplanes produce in both casesthe same value of lift in both cases or will be the value of lift be different? He said that value will be still the same and I was arquining withargueing that if you have tailwind you will have to increase angle of attack which means that paraziteparasite drag will increase so the value of lift will have to increase.

EDIT: Question is: If two same aircraftsaircraft are on same glidepath (descending on ils glide slope) with same IAS but different ground speed, because of headwind acting on one aircraft and the tailwind acting on the other aircraft, will the amount of lift produceproduced by one of the airplanes be different or will be both two valeusvalues be the same?

We had a discussion with friend and we were talking about if the airplane is on approach and the one is landing with tailwind and the other one is landing with headwind, so both have the same value of IAS but the different value of ground speed. Sodoes it means that the airplanes produce in both cases same value of lift or will be the value of lift different? He said that value will be still the same and I was arquining with if you have tailwind you will have to increase angle of attack which means that parazite drag will increase so the value of lift will have to increase.

EDIT: Question is: If two same aircrafts are on same glidepath (descending on ils glide slope) with same IAS but different ground speed, because of headwind acting on one aircraft and the tailwind acting on the other aircraft, will the amount of lift produce by one of the airplanes different or will be both two valeus the same?

We had a discussion with friend and we were talking about if the airplane is on approach and the one is landing with tailwind and the other one is landing with headwind, so both have the same value of IAS but the different value of ground speed. Will the airplanes produce the same value of lift in both cases or will be the value of lift be different? He said that value will be still the same and I was argueing that if you have tailwind you will have to increase angle of attack which means that parasite drag will increase so the value of lift will have to increase.

EDIT: Question is: If two same aircraft are on same glidepath (descending on ils glide slope) with same IAS but different ground speed, because of headwind acting on one aircraft and the tailwind acting on the other aircraft, will the amount of lift produced by one of the airplanes be different or will be both two values be the same?

Post Closed as "Duplicate" by fooot, Romeo_4808N, Ralph J, SMS von der Tann, xxavier
see my comments-- title sounded like a different question than was being asked
Link

If the IAS Descending on a given glide slope (e.g. ILS) at a given airspeed-- is the same but Ground speed is different do we have same valuesize of the lift vector different in headwind versus tailwind?

added 333 characters in body
Source Link
tomas
  • 41
  • 3
Loading
Source Link
tomas
  • 41
  • 3
Loading