The answer to this is a definite "maybe".
YouTube personality Trent Palmer tested this very question. He was actually able to glide further with the engine off than he was with it at idle. It was a very small gain, though, on the order of a few seconds extra flying time per 1,000 feet descent. The people he was with reported similar small gainsdifferent results: One guy said he glided further with a stopped propeller. They theorized that a runningthe engine still generates a small P-factorat idle than with it off, which has to be compensated forbut, increasing dragagain, the difference was miniscule. So, the ultimate answer is that it depends on your exact aircraft.
It's important to noteEdit: My answer originally said that all the planeseverybody involved in the test were STOL aircraftgot the same results. Its entirely possible (and indeed likely)I was working from memory when typing this. Having rewatched the video, I see I was wrong in that other types of aircraft will have, some people got different results (which actually illustrates the point better in my opinion).