Skip to main content
replaced http://aviation.stackexchange.com/ with https://aviation.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This questionThis question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

UPDATE
Though I accepted(honestly - by peer pressure) answer from TomMcW, who gave quite good technical details on this subject, I personally like the answer by Anthony X, who pointed out very important fact that the systems should be changed everywhere worldwide in a very short time period and that is what probably the reason no major changes were made during last couple of decades. So I suggest to read his answer too, not only top-voted one.

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

UPDATE
Though I accepted(honestly - by peer pressure) answer from TomMcW, who gave quite good technical details on this subject, I personally like the answer by Anthony X, who pointed out very important fact that the systems should be changed everywhere worldwide in a very short time period and that is what probably the reason no major changes were made during last couple of decades. So I suggest to read his answer too, not only top-voted one.

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

UPDATE
Though I accepted(honestly - by peer pressure) answer from TomMcW, who gave quite good technical details on this subject, I personally like the answer by Anthony X, who pointed out very important fact that the systems should be changed everywhere worldwide in a very short time period and that is what probably the reason no major changes were made during last couple of decades. So I suggest to read his answer too, not only top-voted one.

added 456 characters in body
Source Link

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

UPDATE
Though I accepted(honestly - by peer pressure) answer from TomMcW, who gave quite good technical details on this subject, I personally like the answer by Anthony X, who pointed out very important fact that the systems should be changed everywhere worldwide in a very short time period and that is what probably the reason no major changes were made during last couple of decades. So I suggest to read his answer too, not only top-voted one.

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

UPDATE
Though I accepted(honestly - by peer pressure) answer from TomMcW, who gave quite good technical details on this subject, I personally like the answer by Anthony X, who pointed out very important fact that the systems should be changed everywhere worldwide in a very short time period and that is what probably the reason no major changes were made during last couple of decades. So I suggest to read his answer too, not only top-voted one.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackAviation/status/663569673255014400
Fix English in title, small fixes in the body
Source Link

Why is the quality of radio communication is bad?

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video -:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).
This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause troubles when pilot does not understand some word and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxingtaxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

Why the quality of radio communication is bad?

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video -


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).
This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause troubles when pilot does not understand some word and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when pilot is just taxing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

Why is the quality of radio communication bad?

Why don't modern planes and ATC centers have good-quality audio for communication? For example in this video:


Or basically any other example of pilot communication(some are worse, some are better).

This is not terribly bad of course, but this is comparable to a cheap $4 headset, the sound is so distorted. This can cause trouble when a pilot does not understand some words and asks to repeat the sentence. And even more problems if the pilot or flight dispatcher are not native English speakers.

Is there some technical reason behind this, like antenna/signal limitations within the plane? The quality is the same when the pilot is just taxiing on the ground, so I suppose this has nothing to do with speed or altitude.

P.S. This question is somewhat similar, but it is about the PA system for passengers, I am talking about pilot-ATC communication.

Source Link
Loading