What would be an easily understood explanation of a "Great Circle Route" for young Civil Air Patrol cadets who are being introduced to aviation and navigation principles for the first time?
6$\begingroup$ greatcirclemap.com/globe?routes=AKL-LHR Use the buttons in the top right. $\endgroup$– Anonymous PhysicistDec 4, 2021 at 1:55
10$\begingroup$ The two current answers are quite good. To be honest, the concept of great circle route should not be difficult to grasp. Whatever method is used to teach it, if it does not immediately stick, any career path in aviation will prove difficult. $\endgroup$– Jpe61Dec 4, 2021 at 12:22
5$\begingroup$ You need a physical globe. Failing that, a large white ball and a marker pen. $\endgroup$– Neil_UKDec 7, 2021 at 6:19
I would recommend that you don't introduce the term first and then try to explain it verbally, but demonstrate it in an interactive, hands-on practical way instead.
Bring a globe, a flat map, and a piece of string to your next meeting. Have the cadets pick a departure and destination city pair. New York to Tokyo might be a good choice, because the effect will be more dramatic over a long distance in the Northern latitudes.
Then have two of them stretch a piece of string in a straight line between those points indicating the shortest distance. Make sure they agree that the string represents a direct line across the surface of the globe.
Then, keeping tension on the string, locate some specific geographical features or cities that the string crosses. Have another small group of cadets find these features on the flat map, and mark them with an "X". The more checkpoints the better.
Once you have as many marks on the flat paper map as possible, simply ask them to connect the dots with a pencil. Don't tell them what to expect, and they will see for themselves immediately that a direct path on the globe equals a curved path on the map, no explanation needed. Let this sink in, THEN you can tell them that the phenomenon is what the term "Great Circle" refers to.
This revelation should open the door to a good discussion and explanation on the challenges inherent in projecting a curved surface onto a flat one, and you can show how landmasses are distorted as a result. Especially the infamous Mercator projection, with its HUGE depiction of Greenland.
7$\begingroup$ Or, after stretching the string taut, hold the globe so they are looking at the string from a point above the globe's equator (Mercator), then rotate the globe so they are looking at it from directly "above" the string. To add to clarity, asking them to visualize the two-dimensional circular "plane" that the string is part of, and estimate where the center of that circle is inside the globe would help in understanding the phrase "Great Circle". $\endgroup$ Dec 4, 2021 at 15:46
8$\begingroup$ I’d also suggest bringing a polar projection map, and showing that the great circle is a straight line there too, so they don’t need a globe to plan flights. That’s how I was taught. $\endgroup$– StephenSDec 4, 2021 at 17:17
$\begingroup$ Good suggestions, thanks! I may edit later, or leave my answer as-is… The other excellent answers supplement the basic idea nicely, and I think in combination provide plenty of good ideas for getting the point across. $\endgroup$ Dec 4, 2021 at 17:22
1$\begingroup$ Also, have them look at the globe+string from different angles. It will appear straight from directly overhead, but curved if seen from an angle. It's all perspective. $\endgroup$– ikegamiDec 4, 2021 at 21:50
$\begingroup$ There are very few things I explicitly remember from "Mr. Roger's Neighbourhood" from when I was a kid, but this demonstration of great circles was one. $\endgroup$– ChuuDec 6, 2021 at 21:07
What would be an easily understood explanation of a "Great Circle Route"
The interest for great circle navigation is a great circle arc between two points is the shortest route between these points. So the idea it to start from the need: What is the shortest route? and see this means finding the route with the smallest curvature. The simple solution happens to be a circle which center is the center of earth, which for this reason is named a great circle.
I added a short explanation about why the shortest route is curved on usual planar maps, albeit this is not part of your question.
Finding the shortest route between New-York and Murmansk?
Going from New-York to Murmansk "in straight line" is following earth curvature. It's a circular path.
The only way to build a circular path between New-York and Murmansk is by cutting earth sphere with a plane including both New-York and Murmansk. (You need a fair stock of oranges to cut randomly and show the section is always circular...)
There are an infinity of planes which contain both New-York and Murmansk. However one is particular: The plane which also contains earth center cuts the sphere into equal halves. It creates the circle with the largest possible diameter. (Another orange to show the great superiority of this plane).
Plane including 3 points: NY, Murmansk and earth center, source
Having the largest diameter this circle has also the smallest curvature.
Having the smallest curvature means the portion between New-York and Murmansk is the shortest path.
This circle which has earth center for center is named a great circle. Other circles drawn on earth are small circles. What we have shown is the shortest route between two points is a portion of great circle. Also visible is that a great circle cut all meridians at different angles, and therefore flying a great circle requires constant heading changes.
Now you'll likely need to explain why the great circle appears curved on a flat representation of this sphere in usual projections (e.g. Mercator). A well known great circle is the day-night line:
The night shade line is a great circle
This distortion appears in projections which try to preserve either lengths (equidistant projections) or shapes (conformal projections).
Some projections will show the great circle as a straight line. This is the case for a gnomonic projection, but also for several projections (azimuthal projections) centered on the mid-point of the path, e.g. stereographic or orthographic. Centering on the mid-point means being in the cutting plane I mentioned in the first part.
Below is a comparison for the great circle between New-York and Murmansk:
The same great circle route in different projections
Explaining why projections can change the shape of the path is difficult without entering into the mysteries of geodesy and how it is impossible to preserve at the same time lengths, areas and angles. A map is designed using the projection which is the most useful for a given use.
However you may remind your cadets that this problem is also visible when shooting a photo, all parallel lines converge to the vanishing point else they don't look real (comparison between regular and isometric perspective).
$\begingroup$ Visualization is the key, and the 2D plane is a better representation of the origin of the term. Great answer! $\endgroup$ Dec 4, 2021 at 17:25
I would do it in a similar way Michael Hall suggested it in his answer.
However, I would first bring two different Maps (e.g. Mercator and Gall-Peters) and ask the flight students a question about the "straight" route between two airports that lead to different answers when using the two maps.
Example: "Does the 'straight' route from Seatle to Hammerfest cross Greenland or Iceland?"
The students will draw a straight line on the two maps and get different information:
Now I would ask them why they got different information. (The answer should be: Because the spherical earth cannot be drawn on a flat map.)
If they are clever, they will have the idea to use the piece of string on a globe themselves now ...
Then you can explain them that the route you get with the piece of string is the "Great Circle Route".