Let's say I have an already-built airplane with known basic characteristics like weight, wing span and wing surface, and I can measure the time of all possible manoeuvres at different speeds.

How can I calculate the roll moment of an aileron in its maximal deflection? The precision of hundreds of [kg*m] is sufficient.


If you know the rolling speed at a given flight speed, you can calculate the aileron effectiveness and use that to calculate the forces. The final rolling speed is reached when roll damping and the aileron-induced rolling moment reach an equilibrium: $$c_{l\xi} \cdot \frac{\xi_l - \xi_r}{2} = -c_{lp} \cdot \frac{\omega_x \cdot b}{2\cdot v_\infty} = -c_{lp} \cdot p$$ Thus, your aileron effectiveness is $$c_{l\xi} = -c_{lp}\cdot\frac{\omega_x \cdot b}{v_\infty\cdot(\xi_l - \xi_r)}$$ The roll damping term is for unswept wings $$c_{lp} = -\frac{1}{4} \cdot \frac{\pi \cdot AR}{\sqrt{\frac{AR^2}{4}+4}+2}$$ and the moment per aileron now is $$M = c_{l\xi} \cdot \xi \cdot S_{ref} \cdot b \cdot q_\infty$$ Calculate the moment for each aileron separately; normally the left and right deflection angles are not exact opposites, which helps to reduce stick forces.

If you only need an approximation, maybe do it like this:

You first need to have all dimensions and the deflection angles. I expect you don't have lift polars of the wing section, so you need to approximate the lift increase due to aileron deflection with general formulas. This is $$c_{l\xi} = c_{l\alpha} \cdot \sqrt{\lambda} \cdot \frac{S_{aileron}}{S_{ref}} \cdot \frac{y_{aileron}}{b}$$ and the moment per aileron now is $$M = c_{l\xi} \cdot \xi \cdot S_{ref} \cdot b \cdot q_\infty = c_{l\alpha} \cdot \sqrt{\lambda} \cdot \xi \cdot S_{aileron} \cdot y_{aileron} \cdot q_\infty$$ Nomenclature:
$p \:\:\:\:\:\:\:\:$ dimensionless rolling speed (= $\omega_x\cdot\frac{b}{2\cdot v_\infty}$). $\omega_x$ is the roll rate in radians per second.
$b \:\:\:\:\:\:\:\:\;$ wing span
$c_{l\xi} \:\:\:\:\:\:\;$ aileron lift increase with deflection angles $\xi$
$\xi_{l,r} \:\:\:\:\:\:$ left and right aileron deflection angles (in radians)
$c_{lp} \:\:\:\:\:\:\:$ roll damping
$c_{l\alpha} \:\:\:\:\:\;$ the wing's lift coefficient gradient over angle of attack. See this answer on how to calculate it.
$\pi \:\:\:\:\:\:\:\:$ 3.14159$\dots$
$AR \:\:\:\:\:$ aspect ratio of the wing
$\lambda \:\:\:\:\:\:\:\:$ relative aileron chord
$S_{aileron} \:$ Surface area of the aileron-equipped part of the wing
$S_{ref} \:\:\:\:\:$ Reference area (normally the wings's area)
$y_{aileron} \:$ spanwise center of the aileron-equipped part of the wing
$v_\infty \:\:\:\:\:\:$ true flight speed
$q_\infty \:\:\:\:\:\:$ dynamic pressure

Depending on the relative chord length of the aileron, this formula is good for maximum deflections of 20° of a 20% chord aileron or 15° deflection of a 30% chord aileron. Remember: This is a rough estimate for straight wings.

  • $\begingroup$ What are the units in the first equation? The right hand side appears to have units of [seconds], assuming p is dimensionless, while the left-hand-side appears to be dimensionless. $\endgroup$
    – supergra
    May 14 '19 at 19:11
  • $\begingroup$ @supergra: No, it's dimensionless. I just realised that I confused p with $\omega_x$ in the first two equations. Thank you for finding this mistake! $\endgroup$ May 14 '19 at 21:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.