4
$\begingroup$

As I know, the engine is independent from the electrical system, and it is supplied from magnetos. However, how can a pilot deal with a magneto failure? And also, when one magneto fails what problems can occur?

$\endgroup$
6
$\begingroup$

One of the things the checklist will have you do prior to lining up on the runway in a piston engine aircraft is a magneto check. That serves to verify that both magnetos are in good working order and that the grounding of both magnetos is intact.

Typically, that will involve bringing the engine to some given power setting (most likely expressed in terms of RPM, but I suppose it could be measured in some other way for some engines; manifold pressure, maybe?) while holding position, then turn one magneto off, then back on, then turn the other off, then back on. While doing so, you verify that there is a drop in engine power, and that the drop in power is symmetric (about the same for both magnetos), and of course that the engine keeps running on either magneto alone.

This verifies that both ignition systems (magneto, spark plug, etc.) are working, and that the grounding of the magnetos works as expected. Absent the power drop, you could have a hot magneto, which isn't a huge problem in flight but could be a major headache on the ground.

If a magneto fails in flight, especially in a single you might not even notice initially; there will be a slight reduction of engine power, just like during the magneto check, but the engine will keep humming along on the remaining magneto. That's part of the purpose of having two independent ignition systems: redundancy.

If there is an engine failure in flight, the checklist will likely dictate something like "select best magneto" at one point or another during the restart sequence. Basically, you'd be doing a magneto check in the air, and choosing whichever setting gives you more power. If one magneto has failed outright, this will very likely cause the engine to stop when you select only the bad magneto; you'd then have to select the other (or both) and restart the engine again.

The checklist may or may not specify that you should land as soon as possible after a magneto failure, but if it were me, I'd want to land regardless and have the problem checked out properly. That would mean either just landing and taxiing back to the ramp (if, say, you're in the pattern doing circuits), or diverting and landing (if you're on your way to somewhere). There's always the possibility that whatever caused the first magneto to fail might cause the second to fail as well, and I'd rather be on the ground at the wrong airport than in the air with a non-functional engine.

|improve this answer|||||
$\endgroup$
3
$\begingroup$

Generally when you have a mag malfunction you want it turned off. The mag may just quit entirely, but there are other failure modes, such as loss of spark to one or more plugs, or worse, a shift in the mag's internal timing, and either of those can cause rough running and potentially detonation (where something causes the timing to drift in the advance direction - the mag's timing is fixed and is set mainly by its orientation on its mounting pad on the engine, but there is an internal timing process for the breaker points when the mag is set up on the bench, called setting the P-gap).

Because of this, one of the normal things to do with a rough running engine is to switch to each mag and see if the roughness stops.

The main effect of having a mag switched off is the obvious one, a loss of redundancy, and a small power reduction. Aircraft cylinders being quite large, the flame has a long way to go to the other side of the combustion chamber when the plug fires. Dual plugs ignites the mixture on opposite sides of the cylinder at the same time, and the flame just has to travel from each side to meet in the middle. One a single plug, the flame travels from the single ignition point across to the other side and this takes twice as long. The effect is more or less similar to retarding the timing a bit; delayed build-up of combustion pressure and less complete combustion, so there is a reduction in horsepower of a few percent.

Also note that if a mag completely stops working while you're in cruise, without any intermediate roughness, you probably won't notice it (unless you were intently starting at the tach or carefully focused in on the sound) and will be unaware of it until the next runup on the ground. You might notice the change if it happens at take off power, on a fixed pitch propeller, from the RPM drop, but if it's a constant speed prop, you won't detect the change as an RPM change and you may or may not notice the subtle change in sound as engine torque declines slightly.

A dormant failure of a single mag that lasts for one flight is an insignificant risk, so it's not like you need to continuously check the mags any more often than once per flight (and even that's overkill; when I was bush flying we only did a full run-up first flight of the day, although on subsequent flights I would usually quickly flip between the two while taxing to the end of the lake for takeoff, just to confirm they were both working).

|improve this answer|||||
$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

If one magneto circuit fails, the engine keeps running, if only with one spark per cylinder, and there may be a very slight reduction of power. The only real risk is that the other circuit may fail too, and in that case the power will drop to zero...

|improve this answer|||||
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ So how can I troubleshoot this problem? is there any solution? $\endgroup$ – Mun Park Feb 20 '19 at 8:54
  • $\begingroup$ Turn off one mag - if there's no drop in RPM then you've turned off a dead magneto and the other one is still good; if the engine stops then you've turned off the good magneto, and the other one is dead; if there's a slight drop in RPM then both magnetos are good. $\endgroup$ – RAC Feb 20 '19 at 9:32
  • $\begingroup$ Troubleshoot, not much you can do airborne. If you had been flying at a high altitude, descending might help if the points had been arcing out. Not much else you can in the air. On the ground you can check to see if there are any wiring problems or mag to plug wiring problems, check for cracks in the case, open the mag & check the points, check the capacitor if it has one, mags for small Cessnas have a nylon gear that ages & breaks, check the shaft to see that it's still being solidly driven, etc. Mags in my plane get sent to a shop in Rockville, IL for IRAN every 500 hours or less. $\endgroup$ – CrossRoads Feb 20 '19 at 14:29
  • $\begingroup$ In the air you don't have a lot of information about the core problem. the only controls you have are :turning off/on magnetos, Carb heat, fuel pump, and/or mixture (or occasionally checking fuses). nothing else while in the air. $\endgroup$ – jeff the tall Feb 20 '19 at 20:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.