4
$\begingroup$

I have Flightradar24 data here. Which are in the following structure.

latitude    longitude   altitude    lastUpdate      velocity
....
49.34240    8.77556 19650   2018-11-01 09:38:09     415
49.35040    8.77490 19550   2018-11-01 09:38:15     414
49.35617    8.77442 19475   2018-11-01 09:38:20     414
49.37045    8.77308 19275   2018-11-01 09:38:24     412
49.38132    8.77208 19125   2018-11-01 09:38:30     411
49.38964    8.77132 19025   2018-11-01 09:38:34     410
49.39796    8.77054 18900   2018-11-01 09:38:39     409
....

This is data for a specific flight. My goal is to split the flight in two parts.

  • Pt 1: Airborne -> Exit cruise time / start Approach
  • Pt 2: Approach Start --> Touchdown

Well, I am not to deep into aviation. My naive approach would be:

If the flying altitude has dropped continuously over the last k points, then the first timestamp is the approach start.

Now I ask myself, in what period of time does a passenger plane leave the cruising phase?

This is different from the pilot calculating the top of descent explained here: What is a rule of thumb for when to begin a descent?

How much ft altitude does an airplane usually lose when it comes out of the cruising phase? And how long does he need for that?

The background is that I want to understand how long a passenger plane usually takes to land at a specific airport from the approach phase. Optimally, I then see that on days when the airspace over the airport is fuller on other days, times, the approach phase takes much longer. Or do you think there are other factors playing an important role? Or is the approach not so correct. Maybe it would be better if I do not look from Approachphase, but from the time where a certain radius was reached. 80km before arrival?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ What you're trying to identify is the "top of descent" point. Clue: Planes try to descend in glide mode as much as possible to save fuel, so the location of the TOD and the rate of descent are linked to the glide ratio of the plane. See What is a rule of thumb for when to begin a descent? and all the linked questions (column at the right of the question) for an overview. $\endgroup$ – mins Feb 7 at 10:35
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Note that aircraft sometimes climb/descend during the en route phase, typically due to weather or traffic. It may be difficult (if not impossible) to reliably distinguish between this and the start of a typical stairstep descent on approach. $\endgroup$ – StephenS Feb 7 at 16:13
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ In a similar project I worked on years ago, we defined to use as top of descent the last point of the horizontal segment preceding the first descent segment that undercut 20000ft. Intermediate level-offs up to I believe four minutes duration were still considered part of descent segment. For flights never exceeding 20000ft we used the last horizontal point at highest altitude where at least five minutes level flight were attained (matching that airline’s short flight cruise planning policy), and if that condition wasn’t matched either, we simply used last point at highest altitude obtained. $\endgroup$ – Cpt Reynolds Feb 7 at 17:05
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ What is the purpose of this exercise? $\endgroup$ – Michael Hall Feb 7 at 17:11
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @ymb1 I don't see how this is a duplicate. That question is, basically, "When should I, the pilot, choose to start my descent?" This question is, "How can I, an observer detect that the descent phase has begun." The pilot of the flight may or may not be following the guidance given in answers to the other question. $\endgroup$ – David Richerby Feb 7 at 17:58
1
$\begingroup$

The distinction when you cross from one phase to another is somewhat arbitrary. However, you can slice this multiple ways depending on your goal: The approach phase could be considered to start at the first point of a published STAR, (Standard Arrival) the initial approach fix of a published instrument approach procedure, when the pilot descends below the class A airspace, i.e. <18,000' MSL, or the first ATC assigned vector off the filed route. (Or some radius as you suggested...)

If you really want to dig into this my recommendation is to go to a local pilot shop and purchase a set of Approach Plates/STARS and a high altitude IFR chart for the area you are interested in. You will likely need help interpreting them if you are unfamiliar with these publications.

If you then have a specific question on your airport of interest there are plenty of experienced people here who are willing to help, but a full education on high altitude IFR enroute and terminal arrival procedures is beyond the scope of this forum.

In lieu of that, if you don't want to take that kind of time to learn something foreign but have a specific airport you are interested in analyzing, please let me know. I have a full set of United States procedures loaded in my iPad EFB and would be happy to post a screenshot with an interpretive description of where I might consider the approach phase to begin for a specific airfield/runway combination.

There are many many different arrival procedures nation wide, into airports of varying levels of traffic congestion. Without a better understanding of your actual goal the question as stated is almost to broad to answer, especially for someone who is admittedly "not too deep into aviation". Good luck with your project.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ +1 for the observation that such lines are "somewhat arbitrary". Going farther & calling them "entirely arbitrary" might even be more accurate. Some STAR's (Denver comes to mind) begin so far from the field that you're often at cruise altitude for the first several points on the STAR. Maybe you step down 2000' for ride or traffic, then cruise level for 5 minutes, then step down another 2000', then cruise level, then get a "pilot discretion" descent clearance, then get cleared "descend via", and then later you actually start down. When did "the descent" start? Call it what you will! $\endgroup$ – Ralph J yesterday

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.