When talking with a local flight school about my interest in starting training, I started asking questions about how the AME process works. The flight instructor then asked me if I had any specific medical issues. Are you required to disclose any health information to your flight instructor? What about if the issue(s) could be disqualifying? Would you get in trouble for lying to the instructor (to avoid judgement or maintain privacy) but NOT lying during the AME?
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
0
Add a comment
|
5 Answers
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
8
When it comes to the AME, you must disclose everything fully and completely. Failure to do so may void any license and insurance and expose you to extraordinary civil and criminal risk.
When it comes to your flight instructor, who is not a medical professional, you do not need to disclose the specifics of your situation. Saying, "I have concerns about passing a Class III Medical Exam due to certain conditions" is sufficient, and is not the same thing as lying. Do not claim you are healthy when you know you are not.
Your instructor may decide not to continue training until a physical is passed, or he may decide just to be a little extra vigilant during training, and delay certain elements or maneuvers depending on the information you choose to provide.
For example: If you choose to disclose vertigo problems, he may avoid steep turns until medical clearance. If you choose to disclose vision issues, he may avoid night-flight.
Regardless, you will need a medical before your first solo flight.
Do not lie to your instructor, but that is not the same thing as disclosing full details of your health with a non-medic.
-
3$\begingroup$ Presumably, you're risking your flight instructor's life along with your own when you are flying together. And their plane, their insurance, their livelihood.. You don't owe them details of your condition, but you should think hard about what you're embarking on here.. $\endgroup$– user33767Nov 28, 2018 at 17:32
-
$\begingroup$ Wouldn't it be also wise to disclose things that can kill you like "I have nuts allergy" or treatments that can kill you in case of emergency? $\endgroup$ Nov 28, 2018 at 20:07
-
1$\begingroup$ Wise? Yes. Required? No. The question is about what is required. $\endgroup$– abelenkyNov 28, 2018 at 20:27
-
2$\begingroup$ @abelenky I believe that instructor is NOT required to train someone if he is not sure it is safe. Actually, as far as I understand, he is required not to allow someone to fly if he has any safety concerns. Freedom not to disclose medical details comes with a price, if used. $\endgroup$– MołotNov 29, 2018 at 13:15
-
1$\begingroup$ @Molot: Did I even remotely suggest otherwise? I explicitly said the instructor may decide not to proceed with training. But the student is still not required to disclose medical details to a non-medic. $\endgroup$– abelenkyNov 29, 2018 at 14:41
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
There's no legal or regulatory obligation to tell your instructor about medical conditions as others have said. There may be rare cases where there are insurance considerations the flight school must take into account, in which case they should explain that.
There's good reasons to be open, however: - Not disclosing a medical condition could increase the risk to both you and your instructor, depending on what that is. The more the instructor knows about you the more they can look out for the specific issues a medical issue may raise - Training works better if there is a rapport and trust between the instructor and student. Lying to an instructor is a breach of trust, and could damage the relationship.
Think of it this way: how would you like it if you were an instructor and found out a student wasn't telling you he/she was prone to panic attacks? And you found out on final approach when the student suddenly went rigid, or worse pulled back on the controls and put you both in a life threatening situation? You'd want to know so you could make an informed choice on whether to take that student on, and if you did you'd probably elect a different training regime, one with more gradual steps.
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
4
There is no obligation to disclose anything to your CFI, just your AME. That said, your CFI may have useful advice about common problems, if you're willing to talk about them, and they may suggest delaying relevant parts of your training until thosr problems are resolved by your AME.
If a CFI (or anyone besides your AME) asks a question you don't want to answer, then tell them that, rather than evading the question or lying (even if only by omission), and they should respect your privacy. Just knowing there's something they don't know is good enough.
If your flight school requires medical forms, then IMHO, find a new one. All they need to know is whether or not you have your medical certificate.
-
$\begingroup$ Flying clubs sometimes have more through medical questionnaires. Some are for insurance data collection, and others are for risk reduction. $\endgroup$– mongoNov 28, 2018 at 17:51
-
$\begingroup$ Some CFIs have more medical background than others, however they are not in a position to do any medical risk evaluation, as much as the FSDO inspectors might bug them for information on a student (when investigating). $\endgroup$– mongoNov 28, 2018 at 17:52
-
$\begingroup$ @mongo: I've rented from FBOs, flight schools and flying clubs, and none ever asked for anything other than my medical cert. No CFI ever asked me medical questions either, though I have asked them for advice on specific issues--as pilots who've dealt with the FAA longer than I have, not specifically as CFIs. $\endgroup$– StephenSNov 28, 2018 at 18:11
-
$\begingroup$ I have first hand experience with several flying clubs, and some of them have rather extensive questionnaires. They don't ask you fine medical details, but one question which raised my eyebrows was whether one had received in-patient medical care in the last 10 years. My student was a mother at that club, and she thought the question was potentially discriminatory, as most women who are mothers have been an inpatient. The membership coordinator told me their insurance agent or underwriter asked that question. More common questions are on alcohol and drug treatment and criminal convictions. $\endgroup$– mongoNov 28, 2018 at 18:17
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
At this stage, when you are just talking about maybe starting to learn to fly, this person is not acting as your flight instructor. He's just a person giving you information about a process. You aren't under any legal obligation to disclose anything to him.
On the other hand, flight instructors often have a decent knowledge of the medical requirements to fly, and might have been able to give you a good opinion on whether any particular condition is disqualifying.
At a later stage, when you are actually taking instruction, it's probably a bad idea to withhold useful information from your instructor. It is likely that a flight school will make you fill in a form which asks about medical conditions, and lying on that would be a very bad idea.
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
2
The reason he asked that is because he thinks you asked an XY question, and thinks the "X" is "I have a medical problem that I fear might fail me on my medical". So he is asking only to answer your query, and he's not wasting time on the Y, and taking the shorter path to X. Not his first rodeo...
As such, he's listening for relevant medical concerns likely to fail you, i.e. That could affect your safety to fly. It would be an "overshare" to mention your excema, HIV status, enlarged prostate, well-managed cancer, eidetic memory, gluten allergy, or need for Viagra.
So answer the X: say why you think you'd have trouble with the medical.
You can always trot out the old "asking for a friend"... But then, expect to have an instructor who takes precautions against you having that problem in flight with him. Really, a lying relationship is not one you want to have in the cockpit of a plane.
answered Nov 28, 2018 at 18:39
Harper - Reinstate MonicaHarper - Reinstate Monica
13.5k1 gold badge28 silver badges59 bronze badges
-
1$\begingroup$ I can positively say that the conversation did not go as you describe. The conversation was about requirements to get a pilot license, which included the AME. I asked about the "process" in general terms (where to take one, cost, ect...). He was the one who brought up the exam details where he then asked me the medical questions. $\endgroup$ Nov 28, 2018 at 18:54
-
$\begingroup$ i wan't there, but I can't see how you would frame a question about the process without it opening the door to his query. It isn't really people's habit to give long general overviews, if they think there's a more easily answered, more specific question underneath it. $\endgroup$ Nov 28, 2018 at 20:48