6
$\begingroup$

Changi airport, Singapore, runway 20C and 20R both point into the sea with no significant obstacle to clear. There is no residential area down there. Next land mass is about 15 km away (Batam, Indonesia) so I guess noise abatement is less of a concern. What could be the possible reason for specify climb gradient at 6 and 7 percent?

Changi notam

$\endgroup$
3
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I don't have a source for this particular notam, but most likely a temporary obstacle such as a ship or a crane (or a ship with a crane) is near the departure end of the runway. $\endgroup$
    – Jimmy
    Nov 21 '18 at 17:41
  • $\begingroup$ @Jimmy yeah i have seen notam about crane and ship before but not sure it direct plane to go up until 2500 ft. $\endgroup$
    – vasin1987
    Nov 21 '18 at 17:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I've had ships completely shut down a runway before. $\endgroup$
    – Jimmy
    Nov 21 '18 at 19:44
2
$\begingroup$

Geographical location of Changi airport

Singapore is on the Straits of... Singapore. This straits is the southern continuation of the Straits of Malacca, both form an international maritime road between Indian Ocean and Pacific Ocean, on a par with Suez and Panama.

enter image description here
(Source)

To add to the bustle, the Changi Naval Base, opened in 2004, is a mere 2 km East of the runways:

enter image description here
(Source)

If that was not enough, there is a shipping channel at the North of the airport, with two terminals near the runways: A ferry terminal, and a cargo terminal.

View of the waters South of Changi airport:

enter image description here
(Source)

Obstructions and climb gradient

Very large ships, including military ones can be close to the runway ends. When this happens, and to take a long takeoff into account, a large climb gradient is in use.

AIP for Changi includes instruction for obstacle clearance calculation.

On the North the climb gradient is at least 3.3%, but is increased based on ships actual height when ships exceed a specified height, and depending on the runway e.g. for RWY 02C:

When there are no reports of vessel movement along the northern shipping channel, or where the reported vessel height is less than 70m (230 ft) AMSL, the aircraft minimum net climb gradient shall be at 3.3%.

Where the reported vessel height is 70m (230 ft) AMSL or higher, ATC shall advise pilots of the vessel height. Pilots, on receipt of this information, shall apply the minimum net climb gradient in accordance with the following table.

enter image description here

For RWY 02L, the height threshold is as small as 35 m and the gradient for a 110 m ship will be 10.7%, i.e. the gradient is twice.

On the South, because the traffic is larger and permanent, the guidance is different:

All departures on Runway 20C/20R shall be on a minimum net climb gradient of 5% until reaching or passing 400 ft. Thereafter, the minimum net climb gradient shall be 3.3%.

So what happened for this NOTAM to be published, requiring a higher gradient of 6 and 7% for RWY 20C/20R? Note this is only 1 or 2% steeper than it is usually. Different possibilities, no certainty:

  • The South protected area border is temporarily closer to the coast.
  • There is a very tall ship in the vicinity.
  • There is an obstacle on the land.

The general formula used for MOC calculation, for North and South departures:

For the above calculations, operators shall use the following information:

a. The most penalizing obstacle is a tall vessel which is on the extended center line of the runway. (ATC shall advise pilots of the height of the tall vessel.)

b. The required MOC is 0.8% of the distance (d) from the departure end of runway (DER) to the obstacle, in accordance with Volume II of ICAO Doc 8168 - Procedures for Air Navigation Services Operations (PANS-OPS) where, in the case of Singapore Changi Airport, the DER is defined as the end of the clearway.

c. The distance (d) for departure Runways 02L/02C is measured from the DER to the shipping channel north of Changi. The distance (d) for departure Runways 20C/20R is measured from the DER to the boundary of the restricted waters south of Changi wherein tall vessels of height above 49m (161 ft) AMSL are not permitted. The distance (d) for the various departure runways is as follows

enter image description here

The procedure above can be used by crews to calculate an optimized climb gradient, in case the default 5% is not retained. This procedure is used to provide pre-calculated MOC for North departures.

Now I want to see the actual departure from RWY 02C! Fly me!

$\endgroup$
1
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I don't have it at hand but Singapore AIP seems to include 6 and 7 degree climb gradient for almost a year already. Will add more when I have better connection. Ps i look from SIN CAAS website for historical AIP. $\endgroup$
    – vasin1987
    Nov 28 '18 at 14:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.