15
$\begingroup$

I am a glider pilot and instructor with a master’s degree in actuarial mathematics. I teach aerodynamics every winter for upcoming glider pilots.

As you surely know, the aerodynamic center is the location where the aerodynamic moment remains constant regardless of the angle of attack – the leverage of the lifting force acting through the center of pressure gets larger for decreasing angles of attack while the force acting through this location gets smaller.

Although I find it easy to understand the mechanisms behind the aerodynamic center, I struggle with understanding how it can exist? How can we be sure that there is such a point in the wing? I know that by definition it is a fixed point, but will it be exactly fixed in practice or just approximately fixed?

Is it not possible to construct an airfoil which will somehow have a discontinuity in center of pressure leverage but delivering the same lifting force in the two situations, yielding non-constant moment around the aerodynamic center?

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ Rolle's theorem comes to my mind... $\endgroup$ – xxavier Nov 16 '18 at 11:28
  • $\begingroup$ Take a look at this question and see if anything there helps. Seems like there’s another question where PK explains this a little differently, but I can’t find it at the moment. $\endgroup$ – TomMcW Nov 16 '18 at 18:39
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ From my understanding the aerodynamic center only exists as a theoretical point in the linearized formulas. I think it only works because the airfoil in the normal angle of attack range has a constant lift derivative (6.28 cl per alpha) and the moment coefficient is a direct function of the lift coefficient. In practice this point is approximately fixed until you enter the stall range (non linear, flow separations,...) or when you go supersonic (shockwaves change the pressure distribution and aerodynamic center) $\endgroup$ – Jan Nov 17 '18 at 13:05
6
$\begingroup$

Assume:

  • Thin airfoil
  • Vary with small angle of attacks
  • Small airspeed
  • Incompressible, attached flow

I hope you feel comfortable with 2 below observations:

$c_l = a_o(\alpha-\alpha_{L=0})$ This means the value of lift varies linearly with angle of attack (*)

$c_m = m_o(\alpha-\alpha_{M=0})$ This means the value of moment at a arbitray point (say point A) on the chord line varies linearly with angle of attack (**)

Suppose we are provied two above equations with all constants are known and the coordinate of point A. Then moment about $x_{ac}$ (unknown) is enter image description here

$$ Moment \space about \space x_{ac} = c_m.q.c^2 + c_l.q.c.(x_{ac}-x_A) $$ $$= m_o(\alpha-\alpha_{M=0}).q.c^2 + a_o(\alpha-\alpha_{L=0}).q.c.(x_{ac}-x_A)$$ $$ = (m_o.q.c^2+a_o.q.c.(x_{ac}-x_A)).\alpha + ...$$ (substitute (*) and (**)) , with q is dynamic pressure, c is chord line

Because moment about $x_{ac}$ is constant when $\alpha$ changes hence the total coefficient of $\alpha$ must be 0, then we solve the equation: $$ m_o.q.c^2+a_o.q.c.(x_{ac}-x_A) = 0 $$ $$ m_o.c+a_o.(x_{ac}-x_A) = 0$$ $$ x_{ac} = \frac{-m_o.c}{a_o}+x_A$$

We now know that the AC exists because on the way finding it, we can find it, it is the root of the above equation which is the coordinate of the AC. It is clear that it is just approximately fixed becasue two observations at the begining are just approximate.

The AC only exist as long as two above observations are true, if they are not linear anymore because the angle of attack is greater than stall angle, you can have two angles with the same lifts but the moments about AC are different.

$\endgroup$
6
$\begingroup$

It exists as a mathematical abstraction for conventionally shaped aerofoils at moderate speeds. In the end it is derived from the centre of pressure. The centre of pressure is the point where the moments of the individual aerodynamic forces over the aerofoil give 0 momentum. This always exist on any aerofoil. Now, the centre of pressure is not at a constant location, it is continually shifting as a function of angle of attack, and it moves quite a lot. However the rate of movement and change in lift force is in proportion to each other, and based on that, the stable point can be found, which for conventional aerofoils at normal speeds is about 25% chord.

Note, that to get this, the proportionality between lift and CP location is a must. You can create any shaped wing cross sections (might not want to call it an aerofoil) which will not have this property and won't necessarily have an aerodynamic centre. Whether it is fit to fly is questionable though. However, they will always have a CP, as it is a simple mathematical property, and it will very likely move with angle of attack. Also note, that the AC does change location with increasing speed, for supersonic speeds it moves significantly backwards.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

In potential flow theory, lift can be calculated as the linear superposition of a contribution from camber and one from angle of attack. While the camber-related part of lift is constant, the angle-of-attack related part varies linearly with this parameter. The center of pressure of the camber part is somewhere at mid-chord (details depend on the camber line; with a Joukowski airfoil the center of pressure is precisely at mid chord). The center of pressure of the angle-of-attack dependent part is at the quarter chord (the center of the area below the chordwise Birnbaum distribution of lift). The important part is the self-similarity of Birnbaum distributions for different angles of attack: The center of pressure of the angle-of-attack dependent part is constant and at 25% of chord for 2D flow and wings of large aspect ratio.

Is it not possible to construct an airfoil which will somehow have a discontinuity in center of pressure leverage[?]

Not in non viscous flow. And you want to minimize viscous effects in order to minimize drag, don't you?

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

All the forces generated on an airfoil are balanced near the 25% chord position, called the aerodynamic center. This location is only effected by airfoil camber, at 0 degree Angle of Attack (AoA), the Center of Pressure (CoP) moves rearward because of its camber producing lift. With positive AoA, below the stalling AoA, the CoP moves near 25% location. The forces are balanced near the 25% location on airfoil/flat plate with positive AoA, because the amount of forces is greater near the leading edge and gradually decrease to the trailing edge.

$\endgroup$
4
  • $\begingroup$ Jascker, first, welcome to Aviation. Please review my acronym expansions to ensure I got them correct. When I looked up CoP in google (aviation cop) I got Changeover Point, yet I doubt that's what you mean here. Remember, many readers of Aviation are simply flying enthusiasts and are neither pilots nor engineers. Please expand all acronyms on first use. $\endgroup$ – CGCampbell Jun 2 at 12:00
  • $\begingroup$ So you are saying that the Center of Pressure is at the 25% chord location at positive angle of attack? What role then is played by the pitching moment coefficient? I'm not sure that it's really true that the Aerodynamic Center really is the point where all forces (or should we better say torques) produced by the airfoil are balanced. If it were true, we wouldn't need to take the pitching moment coefficient into account. On the other hand, the Center of Pressure (which moves as the angle of attack changes) is the point where all torques produced by the airfoil are balanced. $\endgroup$ – quiet flyer Jun 3 at 0:22
  • $\begingroup$ (Ctd) For a given angle-of-attack, if we specifiy the aerodynamic force vector acting at the Center of Pressure, and the location of the Center of Pressure, then we've completely described the pitch torque generated by the airfoil relative to any arbitrarily selected point. The same is not true if we specify the aerodynamic force vector acting at the Aerodynamic Center, and the location of the Aerodynamic Center (which by definition is at 25% chord). Because we also have to specify the pitching moment coefficient. This answer a) appears to miss this point, and b) appears to imply that $\endgroup$ – quiet flyer Jun 3 at 0:36
  • $\begingroup$ (Ctd) This answer a) appears to miss this point, and b) appears to imply that the aerodynamic pitching torque generated by the airfoil relative to the Aerodynamic Center is always zero, at least at positive angles-of-attack. $\endgroup$ – quiet flyer Jun 3 at 0:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.