1
$\begingroup$

New pilot here and I am playing around with a flight simulator game for the B737-800. I need some help understanding where/how one can find out if one has enough engine thrust (%N1) to meet a required climb gradient in feet per minute, not in degrees.

If an airport has a SID that requires, let's say, 1100 feet per minute climb how do I know that the thrust setting (%N1) that I get from the OPT program is enough to give me that 1100 feet per minute when I takeoff? Where do I find that information? Is it in the OPT or is it in performance manuals and, if so, which performance manual? Please explain it in simple terms and with references. Thank you.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Well, if you are able to figure out a climb gradient in degrees, and know the resulting airspeed, and know the wind conditions (how much of a headwind you are flying into), it should be little more than trigonometry figuring out your climb rate in feet per minute instead. Is this what you're asking how to do? $\endgroup$ – a CVn Oct 16 '18 at 8:02
  • $\begingroup$ No, my question is how do I know that the N1 that I get from the OPT is enough thrust to meet the required climb gradient in feet per minute published on the SID? $\endgroup$ – Rallee Oct 16 '18 at 12:36
3
$\begingroup$

How do I know that the N1 that I get from the OPT is enough thrust to meet the required climb gradient in feet per minute published on the SID?

You can't, but read on please.

Variables

A few things out of the way first. A percent N1 is not a percentage of the engine's max thrust. 95% N1 at 20°C at sea-level is different from 95% N1 at 35°C at a 4,000 feet MSL airport in terms of thrust force.

Likewise for the lift; airport elevation, temperature, and pressure, also affect the lift. So for the same runway and SID, you'll get different climb rates at a given speed on different days. And since lift counters weight in a steady climb, how heavy you are plays an important role (as well as how the plane is loaded, i.e., center of gravity).

Gradient and OPT

A SID that shows a climb rate, will also show the corresponding ground speed (put together that's a gradient), in fact it will be multiple rates vs. speeds. Climb rate on its own is not a performance parameter. And while an angle of climb (flight path wrt air) does not depend on the wind, the climb gradient (wrt ground) is affected by the wind (yet another variable). Another variable, turns (bank angle) while climbing.

I'm not sure what OPT is, if it is the free Onboard Performance Tool app from Boeing on the App Store, then note that it requires contacting a Boeing representative for the configuration files, etc. If it is an OPT-like software in the sim, then I highly doubt it can calculate the climb rate; even relatively expensive performance calculators for PC flight sims don't go there.

If you have all the variables, you still can't know the gradient or climb rate at a speed. While a real Boeing 737 comes with an AFM or FPPM (manuals that include performance data), climb gradients with all engines operative are typically not included. The FAA AC 120-91 (Airport Obstacle Analysis) discusses this point:

(...) It is recognized that many AFMs generally contain only the one-engine-inoperative performance for loss of an engine at V1 on takeoff. All-engines-operating performance must also be considered to determine the airplane's flightpath in the event of an engine failure at a point on the flightpath after V1. The best available all-engines-operating data should be used consistent with best engineering practices. Operator's may find appropriate acceptable data in various sources, such as: community noise documents, performance engineer's handbooks, flight characteristics manuals, and manufacturers' computer programs.

How is it done?

So what do you do? Unfortunately not much. In the real world a program like the Boeing Climbout Program (BCOP) -- an example of the aforementioned "manufacturers' computer programs" -- is used to analyze each SID individually (this is different from the three or four takeoff limiting weights pilots are accustomed to).

But even then the analysis may not be presented to the pilots. The airline that is operating out of airport x -- your day-to-day typical not-in-a-hot-valley airport -- would have already checked the extremes (temperature, weight, etc.) against the SIDs for its fleet, and concluded early-on that airport x is not limiting.

The pilot will normally be presented with runway specific thrust setting / weight limit. If you're below this weight, then you may have more than one thrust/flaps setting to choose from. SIDs for the most part (for an airline flying a 737) are not limiting except in extreme airports. Note that the SIDs are designed with the planes/airlines that use them in mind, especially that noise is another important factor.

If you are not an airline pilot and you have your own business jet, then this is a different matter. But because business jets have limited payload/fuel compared to jet-liners, the performance tables are not as complex and indeed can be printed. In other words, those SID figures are more important to general aviation pilots (you may also notice that some SIDs are for turbine aircraft only).

Flight sim

For the purposes of a flight simulator, you can take this as an opportunity to test the impact of each condition one by one. If your 737 allows VNAV arming on ground, you may get "unable next altitude" if the plane thinks it can't make the first restriction, although this is not good practice, as the actual climb is divided into segments, each with a different performance, and the first waypoint may not be representative of the most demanding segment.

You can also test all the extremes at once and see what vertical speed you get. 1100 FPM can be achieved by a 737 in a wide range of conditions, if it can't get to 1100 FPM close to the ground, then getting to cruise will be quite the challenge, i.e., test the conditions to put that value in perspective.

I recommend browsing the and tags, as well as checking the Airbus publication 'Getting to grips with aircraft performance'.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Wow! Hat's off for all the information :) Thank you $\endgroup$ – Rallee Oct 17 '18 at 16:20
  • $\begingroup$ Fantastic answer! $\endgroup$ – Cpt Reynolds Nov 16 '18 at 20:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.