I know that ACARS and CPDLC are 2 different systems, so I can compare ACARS vs CPDLC, but can I do the same comparation between CPDLC vs VDL? Or a CPDLC it’s a VDL?
If CPDLC it is a VDL, ACARS it is a VDL also?
Aviation Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for aircraft pilots, mechanics, and enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityI know that ACARS and CPDLC are 2 different systems, so I can compare ACARS vs CPDLC, but can I do the same comparation between CPDLC vs VDL? Or a CPDLC it’s a VDL?
If CPDLC it is a VDL, ACARS it is a VDL also?
TL;DR : according to the most usual meanings of these acronyms :
To give an everyday-world analogy, the relationship between VDL and CPDLC/ACARS is the same as the relationship between 3G/4G and the web browser/facewhatstime app of your smartphone.
More detailed answer
From a telecommunication point of view, we represent the different functions of a network by different layers. Ideally, one can replace the technology used to implement a given layer by any equivalent technology without impacting the other layers.
The VHF Data Link (VDL) is a technology used to implement the functions of the physical and datalink layers. It means that it is a technology designed to carry any digital data directly from one "device" (aircraft or ground station) to another (resp. ground station or aircraft), independently of its actual content. There are different versions of VDL, namely modes 1 to 4. The current deployments of VDL in europe by ANSPs use VDL mode 2.
CPDLC is an application (application layer). It is directly facing the user, and can use any layer below it (in particular, it can use VDL, HFDL or satcom as layers 1/2)
ACARS is ... a more ambiguous word. It predates the OSI model, and at first it described both the application (text-oriented transmission) and the point-to-point communication technology. Nowadays, pilots use the word ACARS to talk about the application (the printer in the cockpit), and that particular application can, as any application, use any underlying link layer (VDL, HFDL, satcom...). But the old meaning of "ACARS" to describe the original blob of "point-to-point technology + network + application" can still be found today, for example in the acronym POA (plain old ACARS). By the way, the point-to-point technology originally used by ACARS is also called VDL mode 1.