What is the night effect?

I read the night effect takes place in radio navigation, especially VOR and NDB. My questions are:

1. What is its nature?

2. Why does it occur?

3. What are the consequences of it?

• The Wikipedia page for NDB navigation has a pretty good explanation of it. It is also called "Twilight Effect". Mar 17 '17 at 22:28
• It does not just affect radio navigation, it also affects AM radio. Mar 18 '17 at 1:31

In short

The night effect is actually a mirage. Listening to radio communications originating from below the radio horizon is like looking at a looming:

Looming optical illusion, source: SKYbrary

Both are strange things, unless we force ourselves to take into account electromagnetic waves (including light) don't travel in straight line but are subject to regular refraction.

UV and X-rays from the sun create layers of ionized atoms in high atmosphere. Some of these layers have refractive properties, and one acts as a wall preventing waves from the ground to reach the refractive particles.

The night effect is the casual result of a favorable timing: There is a window after sunset where the blocking layer disappears, and the refracting particles are still active, albeit less active than on daytime:

Ionosphere activity changes at sunset

Attenuated waves are redirected towards the ground during this period, possibly to a receiver located further than the horizon. In this phenomenon, ionized particles play the same role than hot air for looming.

Frequency spectrum overview

As your question involves distinguishing several ranges of frequencies, let's make a brief summary of the RF spectrum. Radio frequencies (RF) are a small part of the whole electromagnetic spectrum, along with light and ionizing rays at work in the ionosphere:

RF themselves are divided into "bands" which properties are more or less different. It's sometimes impossible to settle whether a color is green or blue, or yellow or orange, the same is true for these bands, the limits are really not important in most cases.

Wave propagation modes

RF waves propagate using different means at the same time:

• Space wave (electromagnetic "line of sight", i.e. some refraction)
• Ground wave (mostly induced currents)
• Sky wave (large ionospheric refraction).

Space wave vs sky wave vs ground wave

The night effect has its origin in the sky wave, so if you are not interested you may skip the two next sections.

Space wave

Neutral atmosphere (below about 100 km) shows a gradual change in air refractive index, refraction constantly decreases with altitude. The consequence is the space wave is refracted and doesn't travel in straight line (Huygens-Fresnel wavelet principle), as often approximated.

This curvature is about the same for all frequencies in the RF range. When calculating the radio horizon for regular free space propagation, the standard is to use a radius for Earth which is actually 33% larger than the actual radius (4/3 k factor). With this radius, the line of sight can be represented as a straight line.

Ground wave

The ground wave propagation encompasses reflection on ground and obstacles, diffraction on obstacles and horizon, and refraction thanks to current induced in ground.

Because of the refraction and diffraction, this mode of propagation tends to follow Earth curvature, but it mostly affects LF and MF, higher frequencies (e.g. VHF and UHF) do not really take advantage of this propagation.

In ground propagation the wavefront is slowed down where it is closed to the ground. As the wave propagates perpendicularly to its wavefront, this more vertical wavefront can propagate further at ground level without creating shadows.

Ground wave: Wavefront slowed down by ground

Communication distance is increased. However as the ground wave progresses the effect is less and less significant. Vertically polarized waves (NDB and HF voice communication) induce stronger ground currents and propagate better than horizontally polarized waves (VOR variable signal).

The ground wave propagation, like the direct wave propagation, occurs any time, day and night. The third mode is the one of the night effect.

Ionospheric layers and sky wave

Atom ionization consists in losing or capturing one of more electrons, and becoming electrically unbalanced. Natural ionization occurs in the ionosphere under the bombardment of solar ionizing rays which detach electrons from atoms. This takes place in the F-layer at about 300 km, and in the E-layer at about 100 km. Waves can be affected by these layers when they are active.

A layer of ionized atoms makes an efficient refractive material for radio waves. However the lowest D-layer blocks waves during the day because of the ionization of heavy nitrogen monoxide $$\small NO$$) absorbing wave energy as they vibrate under the effect of the wave. This absorption decreases at night when the source of ionization disappears.

Reorganization of ionospheric layers at night

The higher layers are ionized more and more longer than the lower ones, and ionization persists more in the higher layers. The combined effects of D, E and F layers leads to:

• An absorption of LF/MF/HF frequencies by the D-layer at daytime, preventing them to reach the E and F layers able to refract them.

• A refraction at night and twilight when E-layer and above all the F-layer, where free electrons recombine more slowly, and some ionization is maintained overnight, are still active and the D-layer has ceased blocking waves.

The sky wave often proceeds by hops between ionosphere and earth surface, as earth surface, particularly ocean water, is an efficient reflector:

Sky wave reflection on the ground and skips

There is a significant attenuation as the wave bounces back and forth, and in practical the signal is too weak to be used after one or two hops, unless the link is optimized for such operations.

Because the sky wave proceeds by hops, reception is favorable at specific distances from the transmitter and is characterized by minimums and maximums spaced along the direction of propagation, the distance between maximums depending on the frequency.

Sky wave extends significantly the range of LF/MF frequencies. Sky wave impact is less noticeable on VOR and DME range, even if there are exceptional / sparse episodes of VHF refraction by the E-layer (sporadic E). Past VHF there is no noticeable sky wave.

Formally the maximum usable frequency varies with solar activity and is given by the secant law.

As the propagation of NDB frequencies is augmented at night by the sky wave, a NDB can be detected at a greater range by a receiver. This is also true for other mode of communication in the same range of frequency (e.g. voice communication in HF over the oceans).

Because low frequencies are the only ones subject to sky wave propagation, over-the-horizon (OTH) radars use them instead of SHF.

The sky wave propagation is associated with a slow variation, the signal can disappear and reappear a few seconds later. This is due to the instability of the refraction, the heterogeneity of the atmosphere layers, and the recombination of waves after a multi-path trip and a rotation of the polarization. This fluctuation is globally known as fading.

Errors introduced by the sky wave

While sky wave propagation is in general a good thing but, like any other multipath phenomena, it also has negative effects: It changes the polarization of the waves and the direction of the wavefront. As ADF works by detecting the direction of the signal wavefront, a refracted NDB signal introduces inaccuracy in the ADF indication.

The beacon seem to move, and the bearing is not reliable. Some cross check is necessary to confirm the validity of a bearing.

• What an amazingly well-researched answer. Excellent. Dec 26 '17 at 4:03
• Thank you for the great answer. Can you elaborate on your point that "Electromagnetic waves are not entirely understood"? It was my impression that modern Electrical Engineering and physics have had a pretty much complete understanding of electromagnetism (especially standard EM wave propagation) since Maxwell's Equations were devised in 1862. Is your comment about meteorological earth phenomena in particular? Oct 2 '18 at 10:05
• @dionyziz: It's the nature of EM waves we don't understand. Young's double slit experiment in 1803 made us realize our ignorance of "waves", leading ca. 1900 to quantum science and assumptions like duality, superposition of states and Wheeler's delayed choice. Alain Aspect solved the EPR paradox in 1982 and gave credibility to photon entanglement and non-locality. Waves became even stranger, their behavior now supports the idea time may not exist, or at least an effect can happen simultaneously with its cause, even one infinitely remote!
– mins
Oct 13 '18 at 13:50
• Great answer, but EHF stands for extremely high frequency, not extra high frequency. Nov 28 '19 at 1:42
• @Sean: Thanks. We are both right, EHF n. and adj. extremely or extra high frequency; (a) n. a radio frequency in the range 30 to 300 gigahertz (OED), though there are more entries in Google with "extremely". Personally I prefer extra for consistency with ultra and super. Those prefixes are used without consistency across disciplines anyway, e.g. voltages.
– mins
Nov 28 '19 at 11:01