16
$\begingroup$

I am interested in the process of using maritime patrol aircraft in an antisubmarine role. I hope there is some general answer, because I have no idea what such missions look like.

  • How long can such a mission be and how big an area can it cover?

  • What techniques are used during such missions?

$\endgroup$
4
  • $\begingroup$ What is the context of the mission? Are the planes defending friendlies against submarines? Trying to scare them out of a specific area? Just trying to spot them for later strikes? The goal of the mission can affect many of the topics you're inquiring into. $\endgroup$
    – Timpanus
    Feb 19 '16 at 20:53
  • $\begingroup$ Well, I hoped for some general answer. Should I divide the question into a a) in case there is no war and b) there is war? $\endgroup$ Feb 19 '16 at 20:57
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ I think this question is too broad, as it stands. Essentially, it boils down to, "Anti-submarine patrols: tell me everything about them, including how the weapons work." If you can edit your question to be more specific, it would be a better fit for the site. Breaking it into two or three separate questions might also be better: you can provide hyperlinks between the questions if needed for context. $\endgroup$ Feb 19 '16 at 21:12
  • $\begingroup$ One way is to drop multiple sonar buoys across an area to triangulate returns. Hunt. $\endgroup$
    – Steve
    Feb 20 '16 at 5:10
24
$\begingroup$

Update. Added: much more informative P-8 diagram, sonobuoy diagram, ASW training film (see bottom), ESM, minor formatting fixes. Removed: consolidated two sonobuoy loading pics (linked but not shown inline).


This principle method of airborne sub-hunting is using sonar to search a wide area around your ships in the direction of advance. The intent is less tracking subs as it is to deter them from getting into a good position to shoot and/or obtaining a firing solution on your ships.

ASW is a long, complex topic (see bottom for USN training film). This answer will be brief unless someone has more questions.

Airborne sensors include:

Sonobuoys

  • Passive - (omnidirectional or directional) - subs are very quiet today. Detection ranges is extremely short. <100 m by some accounts.
  • Active - all subs are coated with anechoic tiles to absorb acoustic energy
  • A P-3 would go through about 10-30 buoys over a 6-10 hour mission
  • A P-8 can apparently cary 120 sonobuoys.
  • Some vendor specs are available.
  • GREAT video of sonobuoy deployment. (This is one type. Not all are this complex.)

enter image description here Source. Illustrator.

enter image description here Alternate view #1. Alternate view #2. Credit.

Dipping sonar

Unique to ASW helos enter image description here Credit: USN

MAD - magnetic anomaly detector

The large boom extending behind the tail: enter image description here Credit: DoD

  • looks for large metallic masses
  • limitations: short range (100s of meters), which requires aircraft to fly very low over the surface (increasing airframe fatigue and fuel consumption). Descending from cruising altitude also takes time.
  • upside: good localization (spatial accuracy), relatively few false positives.
  • downsides: Equipment is large and heavy. For these reasons, a MAD boom is not included on the current USN P-8, the navy's newest long range maritime patrol aircraft.
  • Counter-measures:
    • Sub can dive deeper to reduce their chances of being detected. Typical SSN operating depths are 400 m. The Type 214 claims a 700 m test depth.
    • Some modern subs are made from non-magnetic steels (eg, German Type 212, Type 214) or titanium (Soviet Sierra, Alfa, and Papa class SSNs, portions of the Typhoon's 5 pressure hulls).
    • Subs also undergo degaussing enter image description here LA-class USS Toledo (SSN-769) prepares to get underway after four days at the Magnetic Silencing Facility. 5 Feb 2010. Credit: USN

Radar

  • Historically, more useful for detecting subs on the surface, forcing them to spend more time underwater, where they were less effective (slower, limited endurance, limited sensor range). For much of WWII, German U-boats were essentially submersible torpedo boats. Most of their attacks were actually made on the surface.
  • Today, our improved radars can detect submarine periscopes (and their wakes) at significant distances, forcing subs to take only very short glimpses. The periscope is actually quite useful for ID-ing targets and obtaining ranges and headings much more quickly than stalking with sonar alone.

Signal intercept, ESM

You may detect a sub communicating over radio. You may also detect a sub if it uses its radar (very seldomly).

Visual

If you're directly above a sub at shallow depth, you can see it. Needless to say, this is extremely rare, but is one reason operating in shallow, littoral waters is dangerous. If you're lucky, you might spot a periscope wake. It's also unlikely you'll see a surface wake. At periscope depth, subs move very slowly. And at operating depths, surface wakes are extremely minute, likely undetectable even by radar and advanced processing, although attempts have been made.

enter image description here Credit

EO/IR

General SA but may occasionally detect exhaust fumes (eg SSK snorkeling) or periscopes/wakes.

Other non-acoustic methods

  • Chemical (eg hydrocarbon sensor) - to detect snorkeling subs recharging their batteries
  • LIDAR - potentially faster than MAD. Limited depth and search band. Less effective in turbid coastal waters. Not used operationally.
  • Radar to detect the minute thermals from warm water heated by reactors. (Claimed by Russians, not demonstrated by US.)

Examples

Land-based maritime patrol aircraft examples: P-3 Orion (modded L-188 Electra), P-8 Poseidon, ,

P-8 Poseidon (modded 737-800ERX).

p-8a from b737 tech site The Boeing 737 Technical Site. Source page with lots more info.

BAE Nimrod (based on the de Havilland Comet)

enter image description here Source

Carrier based platforms include: S-3 Viking, SH-60 Seahawk

SH-60 Seahawk - sensors includes a variable-depth active/passive sonar, sonobuoys, and MAD.

enter image description here MAD bird (orange/red). Credit: DoD

Anti-submarine warfare intro

COORDINATED ASW PART 1 - Coordinated Anti-Submarine Warfare 2089 (HD version below)

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ And of course the mark 1 eyeball, if a sub is to near the surface it leaves a wake. Not a certain sign but a good trigger for looking harder. $\endgroup$
    – user23614
    Feb 20 '16 at 9:35
  • $\begingroup$ @Hephaestus Thanks for the answer! I'v got some explanation also here $\endgroup$ Feb 20 '16 at 12:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.