Aviation Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for aircraft pilots, mechanics, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Instrument approach charts list the equipment required to fly them in their name. For this example let's say we have an ILS or LOC/DME 36R approach. This approach requires an ILS receiver for the ILS portion, or both a LOC and DME receiver for the localizer only portion.

Let's also say we're flying an airplane that has an inoperative glideslope receiver and is otherwise /G equipped with an IFR-certified and up-to-date GPS. Can the GPS be used in lieu of DME in this case?

share|improve this question
3  
I was going to post this as an answer, but I'm not sure it covers all the points: AOPA article for substituting GPS for DME/NDB – Ron Beyer Feb 15 at 17:03
up vote 9 down vote accepted

Yes, the details are in FAA AC 90-108:

7. Usage of Suitable RNAV Systems. Subject to the operating requirements in this AC,operators may use a suitable RNAV system in the following ways.

(1) Determine aircraft position relative to or distance from a VOR (see first note in subparagraph 7b), TACAN, NDB, compass locator (see second note in subparagraph 7b), DME fix; or a named fix defined by a VOR radial, TACAN course, NDB bearing, or compass locator bearing intersecting a VOR or Localizer (LOC) course

You can't substitute GPS for lateral guidance on a LOC approach (section 8(c)), but that's a different scenario. And all fixes, procedures etc. must be loaded from the GPS database, you can't enter any fixes yourself based on lat/long or whatever (section 9(c)(1)).

share|improve this answer

The short answer is, "Yes, GPS can substitute for DME".

The longer answer, splitting some very fine hairs, is that they are not exactly the same thing, and you should at least be vaguely aware of the differences.

DME literally measures distance, by measuring how long a signal takes to make the round-trip.

GPS only knows the position of the receiver and the position of the fix in the database, and just calculates the distance between. That means that GPS is using trigonometry and math to calculate the distance between two points on an idealized sphere, while DME is also accounting for slant-distance.

IF the location of the target fix is affected by slant-distance or by some peculiarity of terrain, there may be a tiny discrepancy between DME's measured actual distance and GPS's calculated distance. But in practice this difference is always going to be extremely small.

share|improve this answer
5  
That's all correct, but since this is a question about instrument approaches it's important to consider what the regulations allow, not just the technology – Pondlife Feb 15 at 17:41
    
Correct except maybe "on an idealized sphere", GPS and RNAV systems use WGS84 datum, hence an ellipsoid. – mins Feb 15 at 18:55

Note that the US government reserves the right to flip GPS back into partly or fully encrypted mode if necessary for military reasons. It isn't likely, but I'd still not want to count on it for final approach.

I stand corrected_ -- this has been replaced by a system I wasn't aware of, per Wikipedia:

...the U.S. military developed a new system that provides the ability to deny GPS (and other navigation services) to hostile forces in a specific area of crisis without affecting the rest of the world or its own military systems.

share|improve this answer
    
this is an absurd position, unless you're have a survivalist mentality that expects nukes to rain down any minute, requiring the gummint to encrypt GPS – rbp Feb 15 at 23:56
    
'partly or fully encrypted' Are you referring to the (historic) Selective Availability mode? – Iain Feb 16 at 2:48
2  
This has IMHO nothing to do with the true usage and legality of usage of the GPS as suggested. – yo' Feb 16 at 8:30
    
Leaving it up just for the correction. – keshlam Feb 16 at 20:43

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.