Take the 2-minute tour ×
Aviation Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for aircraft pilots, mechanics, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This question shows a couple of air hostesses dancing during mid-flight and the co-pilot came out of the cabin to record it.

This made me wonder: Can flight crew or passengers moving around in flight cause the airplane to stall?

share|improve this question
add comment

4 Answers 4

Theoretically? Yes.
Practically? No.

Passengers moving around in an aircraft will have some effect on the balance (center of gravity) of that aircraft, but the proportion of weight for a few flight attendants or passengers moving around on a modern airliner is likely so small as to be negligible. It's not enough of a change to exceed the control authority of the aircraft and cause it to pitch up enough to stall (unless as mah notes you have a substantial number of extremely heavy folks on board and they all stand right up against the aft bulkhead - and even then it's not likely).


I can't find the link to it, but I recall either reading about or hearing about a mostly-empty flight (I want to say on some kind of smaller multi-engine piston aircraft)in in which the half-dozen or so passengers (having had a few "adult beverages") decided to play a friendly prank on the pilots by slowly moving to the furthest aft seats, waiting there for a while, and then slowly moving back to the furthest forward seats.

As I recall the story the aircraft in question had no autopilot, so the pilots had to manually re-trim the aircraft after each round of seat changes. The end result ultimately being that the pilots announced that everyone had to pick a seat and stay in it, or the beer cooler would be locked for the remainder of the flight.

(As you can probably imagine there was no further need to re-trim due to unexpected CG changes following that announcement.)

share|improve this answer
    
In large aircraft, practically no. In a commuter, see Filair L410 at Bandundu on Aug 25th 2010, impacted building. –  Jan Hudec Mar 21 at 7:49
add comment

There was a crash in the Congo that is presumed to be caused when a loose crocodile in the cabin sparked panic, and catastrophically shifted the balance of the aircraft. Not something you hear every day.

share|improve this answer
5  
What's up with this referring to accident news from mainstream media that rarely verify their facts or update the stories? The crash you mention, Filair L410 at Bandundu on Aug 25th 2010, impacted building, is indeed suspected to have been caused by too many passengers moving, but the survivor later changed their testimony regarding the reason. –  Jan Hudec Mar 21 at 7:46
    
@JanHudec Thanks for clearing that up. –  Gareth Ferneyhough Mar 21 at 14:13
2  
@JanHudec On the other hand, the account in the article you link also doesn't make sense. If you look at Bandundu airport on Google maps, there is clearly no "reserve strip" at the side of the runway, just a bunch of scrubby land about 150m wide on each side. But even if a temporary grass strip had been prepared, how would the passengers be able to tell, more than 2km from the runway that the crew were off-line by only 50-100m? –  David Richerby Apr 6 at 16:49
    
@DavidRicherby: Indeed, that story does not make sense. And after more than three years, there does not seem to be any outcome from official investigation either. –  Jan Hudec Apr 6 at 19:04
add comment

I used to teach sport parachuting, and we occasionally pranked the pilots by shifting the weight around.

A Cessna 206 set up for parachuting will have all but the pilot's seat removed, the jumpers sit on the floor. Everyone moves forward for takeoff and then sits back for the ride up. The instructor (me) sits on the floor where the co-pilot would normally be, facing aft, everyone else faces forward. I would wait until the plane was trimmed for climb (and well above 1000 feet) and then motion the passengers to come forward a bit (the pilot cannot see this happen). He adjusts trim as usual, thinking nothing of it. Passengers come forward some more. Trim adjusted again. Eventually we have 5 people wearing 20kg packs all jammed up into the first 2 "rows" and the trim almost fully nose up.

One signal, and 1/3 of the airplane's gross weight quickly moves almost 2 meters aft (in a 4 meter cabin), followed by a sharp pitch up in both the nose and the pilot's blood pressure. The stall alarm usually goes off too.

Mid-size tailgate aircraft used for jumping are regularly stalled by too many people on the tailgate for too long. The rule there is stay forward until it's your turn, then go aft and get out (if the buzzer goes, you get out NOW).

So it's possible to stall a small aircraft by moving the passengers around.

Scaling this up to airline sizes, we find that the passengers are a rather smaller percentage of the airplane's gross weight, and the presence of things like seats, bulkheads and galleys at the rear prevent 300 people from gathering rapidly at the back. The rather large hydraulically powered elevator also has substantial authority over the aircraft's attitude.

So no, a small group of passengers won't be stalling an airliner out of the sky no matter where they stand. Noticed by the pilots: possibly.

share|improve this answer
    
A stall warning at 1000ft with a fully loaded plane does not sound entertaining at all all right :O –  yankeekilo Apr 5 at 17:50
1  
@yankeekilo - probably depends on if you are planning to jump out of it anyway! –  NobodySpecial Apr 6 at 4:04
    
Notice I said "well above 1000 feet". And any pilot who can't recover from a soft stall in a jump-modified airplane shouldn't be flying. ( biggest engine and prop available, leading edge cuffs, flap-gap fillers, winglets - every high-lift mod on the market) –  Paul Apr 7 at 3:55
add comment

An aircraft stalls when it exceeds its critical angle of attack.

Unless the dancing flight attendants all gather aft, and are much heavier than any normal human could be (and even then), I think it's not possible for them (dancing, or being wall flowers) to modify the aircraft's angle of attack.

In short: no.

Further information on aircraft stalls: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stall_(flight)

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.