Take the 2-minute tour ×
Aviation Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for aircraft pilots, mechanics, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

How does it feel when you change from an aircraft to another but of the same model?

Sometimes when you change a car and drive another one of exactly the same model you do feel differences due to various factors like wear and tear, mileage, different service schedules etc.

Does this apply also to aircraft or are they exactly the same?

share|improve this question
2  
If the airframe is the same it will fly nearly identical, especially if the motor is the same hp. Sometimes the switches move to a different spot or the avionics get more advanced but that is the kind of stuff you can practice on a simulator or sitting on the tarmac with a GPU hooked up, or have a qualified friend fly the plane while you sit right seat and play with the toys. –  p1l0t Feb 3 at 15:31

5 Answers 5

up vote 11 down vote accepted

This applies to aircraft just as well as it does to cars.

There are little differences between aircraft from the moment they come of the production line, however these are barely observable. Over time the differences become larger.

For example, jet engine performance slowly deteriorates until the next overhaul, leading to increased fuel consumption. Another source of differences is permanent deformation of the aircraft due to extreme loads. A well known example of this is the B747 of China Airlines flight 006 that had a permanently bent wing.

In airlines flight crew sometimes know that specific airframes have specific characteristics like difficult lateral trim. The flight operations department will observe differences in fuel consumption between airframes of the same model. That can be a reason not to deploy a specific aircraft on long routes.

In addition to the wear and tear like causes there are design difference as well between airframes of the same model. This is described well by Terry. A captain once told me she almost aborted an approach in IMC when the radar altimeter did not come up on final. It turned out the RAD ALT display was at a different position on the screen in this particular aircraft. Their fleet had several second hand aircraft with slight cockpit differences which caused confusion all the time.

share|improve this answer
1  
"In airlines flight crew sometimes know that specific airframes have specific characteristics" -- yep, our most well known problem bird was ship 555, aka Christine, and every pilot who flew it knew it by that name. –  casey Feb 3 at 16:28

In larger aircraft being flown by airlines that buy their airplanes from the carriers that originally bought them from the manufacturers, this can be a real problem. For example, Boeing used to allow considerable customization of 747 cockpits. For example, the forward cockpit overhead panel of 747-100 and -200 aircraft made for TWA had the switches reversed from all other purchasing airlines. The panel was at an angle, neither vertical nor horizontal. TWA treated it as a logically horizontal panel in that if you wanted a switch on, you moved it forward. All other airlines treated it as a logically vertical panel in that if you wanted a switch on, you moved it up. Thus, from the pilot's point of view, to turn on a switch on a TWA airplane, you moved the switch in the reverse direction of the other airplanes. Things got especially bad when switches from, say, an ex-Pan Am airplane were put in an ex-TWA airplane. Towards the end of my career (retired 1999), if I was in an ex-TWA airplane, I always looked directly at an overhead panel switch before throwing it. The differences section of the QRH (Quick Reference Handbook) of both 747 carriers I flew for was lengthy.

As I remember, the FAA finally stepped in and required Boeing to offer less cockpit customization.

share|improve this answer

The biggest differences that you will notice is that, especially on older models, the panel in the cockpit is not standardized and the avionics can vary wildly in both location and operation. As an example, take a look at these two 172 panels:

C172-1 C172-2

Lighting is another thing that can vary from just barely passable to sleek modern solutions that allow you to see everything easily.

You should definetely take some time with any new airplane on the ground and learn where everything is before you take it up for an actual flight.

Aside from these differences, as others have pointed out, you may notice some small performance differences depending on the total time on the engine, etc. These usually aren't that big of a difference as long as they are properly maintained.

share|improve this answer

A lot of this depends on what you mean by "the same model" - there is a lot more variation between aircraft than there is between cars, and a lot more that the pilot can customize. While every Ford Mustang you get in will be relatively similar even if you're going from mid-1960s to early 2000s models you could get in two planes that came off the assembly line right after each other yet seem completely different depending on what their owners have done to the avionics and airframe over the years.

On top of the avionics and panel layout and possible engine performance variation every aircraft is different: for the most part they're hand-assembled (even airliners to some extent) so there's variation there, and planes last a long time so each one has aged differently.
One airframe may have been in accidents and had major repairs that weren't quite to spec, another may have rigging issues (I flew a trainer that required left rudder in a right turn to remain coordinated), so you have to develop a feel for each plane you fly.


As another example of variation between planes consider that both Cessna and Piper have produced very long-lived "models": Cessna's 172 and Piper's Cherokee family (which I've picked because both are still in production today).

By one measure these are the same "model" (It's a Cessna 172, or a Piper PA28), and they'll fly largely the same as any other plane of the same type.
By another measure there are many different models in each family.

For example you could have a Cessna 172 E with mechanical flaps, or a Cessna 172 F with electric flaps. You could have a Cherokee C model with "barn door" air vents and overhead trim, or an E model with the vents in the wing root and a trim wheel between the seats.

Sometimes these differences won't matter much to the pilot - the difference in air vent location in the Cherokees doesn't really affect your flying. Other times it's a difference you need to be aware of, like whether your flap controls are a switch on the panel or a lever on the floor in the Cessna, or whether you reach up or down for trim in the Cherokee.

share|improve this answer
3  
172's are a lot worse for this than people realize. I've found that the early models (I've flown a B, C, M, and P) are very sluggish with power changes (due to having a wildly different engine than the later models) and their landing flare doesn't look anything like newer 172's, which is the biggest issue for me. Newer 172s are obviously more powerful but they also seem a little lighter on the controls despite having a higher weight. Anyway, my point is that I always tell people not to assume they know how a plane will fly just because they've flown the same model before. –  StallSpin Feb 4 at 4:30

Engine performance and control rigging are probably two of the more obvious ways this is noticeable.

In aircraft with cable or pushrod controls, the system can develop slack and create a null zone where moving the controls does nothing.

As far as engines go, every engine wears differently. Some get crappy field overhauls and never really produce their original power again. Others are nearing end of life and have low compression in one or more cylinders.

Unless you're flying aircraft from an exceptionally well maintained fleet that distributes the flight hours fairly evenly, moving between models will almost always highlight a difference or two.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.